I assume, but don’t know, that Hamas has a spokesperson that wrote it, and sent it to news agencies.

A. Having credentials does not mean one produces quality work. The academic system is broken.

B. I ignore all ‘sources’ that skip basic inconvenient facts to support their narrative.

C. The basic facts of the region include brutality and conflict from all sides. The Palestinians are not some holy angels. They were fucked by history, but they are not victims.

D. There is no one consistent definition of Palestinian. Even UNRWA made a mess of the matter. For example, they included Arab job seekers that got stuck in the region.

E. Point D. is important, as a more consists definition is required. For a long term solution. One that is not ‘from the river to the sea’ or forever war. We are entering into a period of rapid changes (not for the better) due to climate change. If no solution will be found soon, there will never be one. As we are losing our ability to build.

F. If someone feel joy from mass murder (covering it up in terms like resistance dose not change what it is) he is a stain on humanity.

I will read your next reply, but will not reply to it.

Are really going after the words of grade F pseudo historians of the like of Nur Masalha? LOL

What a waste of time

I don’t trust al mayadeen, as they are Hizzbulah mouthpiece. But they will not spread fake news to support Israel.

https://english.almayadeen.net/news/politics/hamas-mourns-leader-fateh-sharif-assassinated-by--israel--in

Let break it down.

Gaza has never stopped being under Israeli occupation since 1967

False, Israel left Gaza in 2005, the blockade started after Hamas fired rockets into Israel.

Hamas only exists because of the Apartheid Occupation of Israel and the daily violence that has subjected Palestinians to for generations.

False, Hamas is a modern, local, branch of the Muslim Brotherhood. A movement that was already active in the area in 1929 (1929 Palestine riots).

Israel has always been the obstacle for peace, and has been the one preventing a ceasefire.

This is why Israel has peace with Jordan and Egypt. Yes. Also, remind me, who broke the ceasefire on 2006? On 2023? Not Israel.

It is not ‘99% Muslim because they murdered everyone else’ that’s an insane racist lie. Palestine has historically been a safe haven for people of every religion seeking asylum from persecution.

Like the Jewish people that lived in Gaza in 1929? Like the Jewish people of Zfat in (1834 looting of Safed as an example, there are more)? The Christian population in most, if not all, Muslim controlled territories has declined due to persecution by Muslims.

The word may will be used for any evidence that is not strong as said UNRWA employees bursting into the OIOS armed with guns, marked with Hamas headband and shouting slogans. Even if they have pay slips from Hamas or video evidence they will use the word may. It’s a common usage in formal text. But don’t trust me, open scientific papers from high impact journals. You will find the word ‘may’ being used in a similar fasion.

As for evidence from Israel, it goes down to he-said. As Israel claims they provided evidence[0]. As both sides have interest to lie, I don’t believe any of them.

It will take a lot of time for a clearer picture to emerge. But in the meantime you can collect puzzle pieces by your self. For example, Hamas’ announcement on the death of head of operations in Lebanon [1] raised a familiar name! The beloved school manager that UNRWA suspended [2]

0 - https://govextra.gov.il/unrwa/unrwa/ 1 - https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/sep/30/first-thing-hamas-says-israeli-airstrike-has-killed-head-of-its-operation-in-lebanon 2 - https://unwatch.org/fatah-silent-as-hamas-union-chief-suspended-by-unrwa/

Thorough investigation takes time.

https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/08/1152841

Till August the UN found that nine had to be fired. By their next report we will see more double dippers.

I would have zero problem with West Bank Palestinians striking back at the local Jewish settlers. I will feel no joy from that, but the local settlers earned that. I would much prefer if the world banking system will block them and they will be all charged with war crimes.

UNRWA should be dismantled completely. They double dipped as Hamas members, made up funny definition for refugees, promoted conflict and lead to no long term solution. UNHCR may be more successful, after all, they are good enough for all other refugees.

The battle of Gaza in 2007 happened after Hamas dried the PA security and opened a war on Israel by kidnapping a soldier from within Israel through a tunnel.

The uselessness of the UN Peacekeeping Force is the reason Israel and HA are at war, again. They failed to enforce 1701.

If to judge by other places in the world, they were probably too busy taking bribes and sexually abusing the locals.

The person above you claimed I work for Netanyahu. Hell no.

Hamas seized power after a civil war, brought on by an attempted coup by the PA backed by the US and Israel. This attempted coup led to the Hamas attacks on Israel. They did not randomly break all agreements and started shooting rockets.

Hamas was always deeply unhappy with the Israeli presence, but they hadn’t become really openly violent before that point.

Hamas’ charter calls for the destruction of Israel and death to all Jews. They showed previously to 2006 that those are not empty words. In 2006, after the elections, they refused to respect previews agreements Israel made with the PA and then they dug a tunnel into Israel and kidnapped an Israeli soldier.

All the while not paying salaries to the PA defence forces and keeping a private military body.

There was no coup, no one wanted to continue working with them after that. So the president of the PA replaced the prime minister.

What the fuck is this insane statement. Call the police?

There is no police for international matters.

The people of Gaza were not fucked by Israel. They were fucked by history. Did Israel add to the fire? Yes, did it cause it? No.

Murdering random people in their house is not fighting for freedom.

Kicking Hamas out is fighting for freedom.

I’ll call the same to a Jewish person that will show happiness to the current happening in Germany. Because I met such people, both “Palestinians” (that never lived there) and “German” Jews (that never lived there). Both had shallow world view that had just enough depth to spew hate. Not even one bit deeper.

I didn’t call her a bitch, cus that word works only toward women, and that is wrong.

You are justifying me calling her hateful.

What I expect from a non-hatful person is to condemn by action, not by side. Adults can handle that complexity.

Everything Israel does in the West Bank is wrong. The 7th of October attack lead by Hamas from Gaza is wrong.

If you cheer for an act of evil, if it makes you feel joy, you are evil, you are hateful.

Removed by mod

Fuck Netanyahu, fuck his Nazi government, fuck Hamas, fuck every Hamas supporter, fuck every person that cheered on the 7th of October, fuck every person that went to burn houses in the west bank, and fuck you, for spreading hate and thinking (you are bad at that part) that a highly complex conflict that goes back hundreds of years is one sided.

It was also cool in Iran, that how they got stuck with the current regiment. Stupid kids.

You are mixing the west bank and Gaza 🤦‍♂️

There is no apartheid in Gaza, as no part of Gaza is under Israeli management. Israel placed a blockade on Gaza from the sea (and not from Egypt) because Hamas was firing rockets (indiscriminately BTW) into it civilian population.

There is an apartheid in the West Bank with the Jewish variation of Nazim running the show. That should stop. But that happens in the West Bank, where less than 6% of Israeli live.

The 7th of October attack was imitated from Gaza, by Hamas, which see both Israel and Fatah as enemies (Hamas throw Fatah people off roof tops in 2007, that how they got into power).

You are justifying an islamfascist body asymmetrical war on a neighboring country. By mixing geogrphy.

I’m not sure if you are troll, or mentally retarded.

Israel left Gaza in 2005, and placed no blockade. Hamas to power in 2007 and broke all past agreements with Israel and started to launch rockets into Israel. This lead to the blockade.

The civilian population is no shield against a blockade.

If you started to fire your gun on my home at random hours I would have locked your door from the outside and set your home on fire with, or without, your family inside. This is common sense.

Gaza strip was part of Egypt till the six days war. Egypt refused to take it back. Israel refused to pass law expending their border to include Gaza strip and in 2005 made it illegal for their citizens be stay there.

What in this chain of events makes you think they are the same country?

Removed by mod